Moral responsibility and alternative possibilities. Frankfurt submitted 2 years ago by coffeeandbitters comments. Frankfurt defenders have attempted to satisfy this demand in various ways. So responsibility and alternative possibilities go together after all, and pap would remain truemoral responsibility requires alternative possibilitieswhen free choices are not determined. They allow for what william james called open and ambiguous futures. Moral responsibility and alternative possibilities, edited by david widerker and michael mckenna, draws together the most recent work on frankfurts thesis by leading theorists in the area of free will and responsibility. An agent acts freely in a way that is relevant to his moral responsibility. Frankfurt cases the principle of alternate possibilities. Moral responsibility and alternative possibilities published on 01 jan 2004 by brill. Frankfurt alternative possibilities and moral responsibility here is an in. Request pdf moral responsibility and alternative possibilities is choice necessary for moral responsibility. The case straightforwardly includes alternative possibilities. I argue that being blameworthy doesnt require the belief that one could have done otherwise, and draw some conclusions about the epistemic conditions for responsibility.
Your instructor credentials will not grant access to the hub, but existing and new users may request access here. Weekly discussion moral responsibility and alternative. Possibilities download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility harry g. Recent work on free will and moral responsibility 99 time of free action, the agent could not have done otherwise, but in which alternative courses of action are not ruled out by a sign or other vehicle that illicitly presupposes a deterministic relation. The principle of alternative possibilities is the claim that moral responsibility requires the ability to have done otherwise. This possibilities page is now about the philosophical difference between. David william palmer one of the most significant questions in ethics is this.
Pdf frankfurt alternate possibilities and moral responsibility. Essays on moral responsibility and alternative possibilities fsu. The pap comes in two flavors, depending on whether it claims that alternative possibilities are necessary for moral responsibility or necessary for free will. This book draws on the work on frankfurts thesis by leading theorists in the area of free will and. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility paper. Free will and responsibility in philosophy of action categorize this paper. Since then, frankfurts thesis has been at the center of philosophical discussions on free will and moral responsibility.
The principle of alternate possibilities as sufficient but not. The moral significance of alternate possibilities, in d. This essay challenges the widely accepted principle that a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done. Principle of alternative possibilities is that free agents are ultimate originators of their willings and actions. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility jstor. Frankfurt, alternate possibilities and moral responsibility john martin fischer, responsiveness and moral responsibility harry g. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading moral responsibility and alternative possibilities. In perspectives on ignorance from moral and social philosophy peels, ed.
The principle of alternate possibilities may in this way derive some credibility from its association with the very plausible proposition that moral responsibility is excluded by coercion. An agent is morally responsible for an action only if he could have done otherwise. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility, journal of philosophy 66, 828839. As the majority of the essays appear here for the first time, moral responsibility and alternative possibilities offers the. Moreover, it seems reasonable to contend that a requirement of this sort is not merely a necessary condition of little consequence, but that it. Frankfurt cases also known as frankfurt counterexamples or frankfurtstyle cases were presented by philosopher harry frankfurt in 1969 as counterexamples to the principle of alternate possibilities pap, which holds that an agent is morally responsible for an action only. Moral responsibility and alternative possibilities book. The principle of alternate possibilities lets focus on the following two widely shared beliefs. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility 83i being unable to do otherwise. Essays on the importance of alternative possibilities kindle edition by widerker, david, mckenna, michael.
And does choice imply alternative possibilities of some significant sort. Pdf defending the principle of alternate possibilities. View enhanced pdf access article on wiley online library html view download pdf for offline viewing. Responsibility, indeterminism, and frankfurtstyle cases. As the majority of the essays appear here for the first time, moral responsibility and alternative possibilities offers.
Essays on the importance of alternative possibilities. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility mit. The requirement that moral responsibility presupposes an agents ability to act freely is reflected in the principle ought implies can. Alternative possibilities and causal histories 1 two incompatibilist intuitions the claim that moral responsibility for an action requires that the agent could have done otherwise is surely attractive. Choice, moral responsibility and alternative possibilities. Frankfurt, freedom of the will and the concept of a person. Alternative possibilities and moral responsibility turned the philosophical debate surrounding this issue on its head. Harry frankfurts thesis has been at the center of philosophical discussions on free will and moral responsibility. The garland science website is no longer available to access and you have been automatically redirected to. Suppose that john is on his way to a voting booth and is undecided about whether to vote for candidate a or. All instructor resources see exceptions are now available on our instructor hub. The attacks, led by frankfurt, on the principle of alternative possibilities do not threaten this deeper libertarian conception of freedom and moral responsibility at all.
Three new principles chapter 2 responsibility for actions 2. Alternative possibilities and causal overdetermination in. From these two claims, we can validly derive by hypothetical syllogism the. Frankfurt alternate possibilities and moral responsibility handout. In an influential paper, alternate possibilities and moral responsibility 1969, the american philosopher harry frankfurt questioned whether the ability to do otherwise is truly necessary for freedom. A person may well be morally responsible for what he has done even though he could not have done otherwise. Article pdf alternative possibilities and moral responsibility harry g. Frankfurt, alternate possibilities and moral responsibility. Frankfurt alternate possibilities and moral responsibility. The incompatibilist argues in the following way for his conclusion that moral responsibility is incompatible with determinism.
Moral responsibility without alternative possibilities. C if determinism is true, then we do not act freely. This idea is captured by the principle of alternative possibilities. P1 you act freely only if you could have acted otherwise. The requirement of alternative possibilities for moral. Explores the relation between free will and moral responsibility. Ignorance, alternative possibilities, and the epistemic conditions for responsibility. This paper will relate these questions to the argument initiated by harry frankfurt that alternative possibilities are not required for moral responsibility, and to john martin fischer and mark ravizzas extension of that argument in terms of guidance control in a. Alternative possibilities are one of the key requirements for the freedom component of free will, critically needed for libertarian free will. Second, they have challenged pap indirectly by arguing that there are alternative conceptions of freedom from freedom of choice that, it is claimed, are not reliant on alternative possibilities but are sufficient to capture the freedom required for moral responsibility. This isnt exactly the same as the leeway condition, which is about the conditions for free will rather than moral responsibility. Frankfurt alternative possibilities and moral responsibility. Home about us subject areas contacts advanced search help help.
Libertarianism and the philosophical significance of frankfurt scenarios find. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility university college. Frankfurts thesis the principle of alternate possibilities pap that a person is morally responsible for what he has done only if he could have done otherwise. Onsite pdf moral responsibility without alternative possibilities, in moral responsibility and alternative possibilities. Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility chapter 1 the.
Alternate possibilities and moral responsibility harry. Alternative possibilities and moral responsibility. Moral responsibility alternate possibilities and moral responsibility 1969 learn with flashcards, games, and more for free. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Click download or read online button to get possibilities book now. The principle of alternate possibilities as sufficient but not necessary for moral responsibility.
201 516 239 1562 179 1274 1411 285 1194 860 202 557 585 717 99 373 1199 961 1152 446 1434 674 5 106 840 685 1251 1236